Judge rules David Mueller failed to prove Taylor Swift personally set out to have him fired after 2013 photo opportunity
A judge on Friday threw out a Denver radio hosts case against Taylor Swift in a trial that delved into their duelling lawsuits over whether he groped her during a backstage meet-and-greet and whether she and her team ruined his career.
US District Judge William Martinez determined that the pop star could not be held liable because David Mueller failed to prove that she personally set out to have him fired after the 2013 photo op. His identical allegations against Swifts mother and her radio liaison will go to jurors for a verdict.
Mueller denies groping Swift and sued the singer, her mother, Andrea Swift, and their radio handler, Frank Bell, seeking up to $3 million as compensation for his ruined career.
The singer-songwriter said in her countersuit that she wanted a symbolic $1 and the chance to stand up for other women. The jury will still consider her claim.
Swift teared up as the judge read his decision, saying there was no evidence that her actions were insincere. Afterward, her team smiled and embraced. Muellers side did not speak.
The move came after days of testimony from the singer and others and just before jurors were set to hear closing arguments.
Swift spent an hour on the witness stand on Thursday defiantly recounting what she called a despicable and horrifying and shocking encounter before a concert.
He stayed attached to my bare ass-cheek as I lurched away from him, Swift testified. It was a definite grab. A very long grab, she added in her testimony.
Swifts testy exchange with Muellers attorney occasionally elicited chuckles even from the six-woman, two-man jury. She got a laugh when she said her security guard saw Mueller lift my skirt but someone would have had to have been underneath her to see the actual groping and we didnt have anyone positioned there.
Swift testified that after the photo was taken she tried to get as far away from Mueller as she could. She said she told him and his girlfriend, who was also in the photo, thank you for coming in a monotone voice before they left.
She also said she was stunned and did not say anything to Mueller or halt the event after he left because she did not want to disappoint several dozen people waiting in line for photos with her.
In the image, shown to jurors during opening statements but not publicly released, Muellers hand is behind Swift, just below her waist. Muellers then-girlfriend, Shannon Melcher, is on the other side of Swift. All three are smiling.
Melcher testified on Friday that she saw nothing happen during the brief encounter and that she and Mueller were rudely confronted and escorted out of the arena that evening. Melcher said Mueller was devastated by the accusation.
She said she and Mueller started out as co-workers at country station KYGO-FM and became romantically involved in February 2013, a few months before the concert. They drifted apart late in 2013, but Melcher says they remained friends.